Why do consumers punish companies that are committed to sustainability? Why does well-intentioned ESG communication increasingly lead to shitstorms instead of sympathy? How do other companies manage to communicate their responsibility credibly and build trust in the process?
The answer lies in a fundamental change in the communications landscape. ESG—once the magic word for responsible corporate governance—has gone from being a euphemism to a cacophony. What was considered progressive yesterday is now being critically questioned today.
The perfect storm: When ESG becomes a target
The figures speak for themselves. While greenwashing cases declined by 12 percent worldwide, Switzerland recorded an increase of 17 percent according to a RepRisk study. Sixty-one Swiss companies were involved in greenwashing allegations – a warning sign for everyone involved in sustainability communication.
This development is no coincidence. The ESG backlash that began in the US has reached Europe. What started as a movement for greater corporate responsibility is becoming increasingly politicized and polarized.
The consequences for companies are complex: they are caught between regulatory requirements that demand greater transparency and a public that views any sustainability claims with skepticism. Many tend to reduce their communication on ESG issues to the absolute minimum—a phenomenon known as "greenhushing."
But silence is not the answer. Investors, customers, and employees continue to expect answers to sustainability questions. The trick is to meet these expectations without falling into the greenwashing trap.
New rules of the game: Switzerland's ban on greenwashing
Since January 1, 2025, stricter rules against greenwashing have been in force in Switzerland. The new Article 3(1)(x) of the Federal Act Against Unfair Competition (UWG) clearly defines that it is unfair to "make statements about oneself, one's works or services in relation to the climate impact caused that cannot be substantiated by objective and verifiable evidence."
This regulation has far-reaching consequences. It affects not only large companies that are required to publish sustainability reports, but also all voluntary disclosures and advertising claims. Every climate claim—whether "CO₂-neutral," "sustainable," or "environmentally friendly"—must be substantiated.
Enforcement takes place on several levels: In addition to civil law claims, violations can lead to reports to the State Secretariat for Economic Affairs (SECO) or complaints to the Swiss Commission for Fair Trading. Consumer Protection Switzerland has even set up a reporting platform where consumers can report suspicious cases.
A recent example illustrates the consequences: the Fair Trading Commission upheld a complaint against a helicopter company that advertised its flights as "100 percent climate neutral." The reasoning: the claim was absurd and could not be substantiated.
Double materiality as a compass
Modern sustainability communication requires a new understanding of relevance. The concept of double materiality, which was first introduced by the EU in 2019, is also gaining ground in Switzerland.
Companies must adopt two perspectives: on the one hand, the "inside-out perspective" – what impact does the company have on the environment and society? On the other hand, the "outside-in perspective" – what impact do sustainability issues have on the business model?
This dual perspective is more than just a regulatory obligation. It forms the basis for authentic communication. Only those who understand and integrate both perspectives can speak credibly about sustainability.
A real-life example: A Swiss financial services provider communicates not only how it promotes sustainable investments (inside-out), but also how climate risks affect its business model (outside-in). This transparency builds trust and shows that sustainability is taken seriously.
Strategic sustainability communication: striking a balance
There is a fine line between greenwashing and greenhushing when it comes to successful ESG communication. The solution: strategic sustainability communication based on facts that addresses both progress and challenges in equal measure.
Go for Impact and the Greenwishing Association have developed five principles of credible environmental communication that serve as a strategic compass. These principles emphasize transparency, measurability, and the recognition of limitations.
Successful ESG communication follows a clear pattern. It begins with the integration of sustainability aspects into the corporate strategy. This leads to concrete goals that are measurable and realistic. These goals are then communicated in an evidence-based manner in accordance with established standards.
The challenge lies in striking the right balance. Statements that are too vague come across as implausible, while overly detailed information can be overwhelming. The trick is to present complex sustainability issues in a way that is tailored to the target audience.
From obligation to opportunity: ESG as an opportunity
Despite all the challenges, ESG communication offers enormous opportunities. Companies that communicate their sustainability performance authentically differentiate themselves in the market and build long-term stakeholder relationships.
The Content Marketing Study 2025 shows that 64 percent of Swiss companies use content marketing to strengthen customer retention and loyalty. ESG issues are playing an increasingly important role in this.
Sustainability is becoming an integral part of the brand story. Companies that transparently document their progress and also report on setbacks gain credibility. They show that sustainability is a process, not a state.
An example of successful integration: A Swiss manufacturing company publishes quarterly updates on its sustainability goals. In addition to successes, challenges are also addressed. This transparency has led to higher employee motivation and stronger customer confidence.
Practical tools against greenwashing
Avoiding greenwashing begins with systematically reviewing your own communications. The seven characteristics of greenwashing serve as a checklist:
- Hidden trade-offs
- Lack of evidence
- Vague statements
- Irrelevant information
- Emphasize the lesser evil
- untruths
- Incorrect labels
Every communication measure should be checked for these characteristics. In addition, a structured process is recommended: from data collection and verification to target group-oriented preparation.
Specific measures for practical application:
- Establishment of an internal review process for all sustainability statements
- Documentation of all receipts and calculation bases
- Regular training for communications officers
- Involvement of external experts in critical issues
The future of ESG communication
Regulatory requirements will continue to increase. Switzerland is increasingly aligning itself with EU standards, even without formally adopting them. The planned threshold for sustainability reporting is to be lowered from 500 to 250 employees.
At the same time, ESG communication is becoming more professional. Data collection tools, reporting standards, and strategic planning frameworks are developing rapidly. Companies that invest in skills and systems now will reap the benefits in the long term.
The future belongs to integrated communication. ESG is no longer treated as a separate issue, but permeates all areas of the company. From product development to the supply chain to employer branding—sustainability is becoming the common thread.
The most important insight: ESG communication is not a one-way street. Successful approaches are characterized by dialogue with stakeholders, acknowledging uncertainties, and continuous improvement.
Your path to authentic sustainability communication?
Would you like to communicate your ESG performance credibly while avoiding legal pitfalls? Brand Affairs supports you in developing customized sustainability communications. With our experience in the Swiss communications landscape and our network of sustainability experts, we work with you to create CSR PR that builds trust and achieves results.
Contact us for a no-obligation consultation. Together, we will develop an ESG communication strategy that suits your company, meets regulatory requirements, and convinces your stakeholders.